Mothballs are commonly used to protect clothing and other fabrics from destructive pests, such as moths and carpet beetles. Traditionally, mothballs have been placed in storage areas to prevent infestations, particularly in items made from natural fibers like wool, fur, and cashmere.
However, their strong chemical fumes can also be useful in repelling a variety of other pests beyond moths.
In this article, we’ll explore the various uses of mothballs, what they protect against, and the potential risks involved in using them.
What are mothballs?
Mothballs are small balls or flakes composed of either naphthalene or paradichlorobenzene—two potent pesticides designed to kill and repel moths, particularly their larvae, which are notorious for damaging clothing and fabrics made from natural fibers. These chemicals slowly sublimate, releasing strong fumes that deter moths and other pests. Traditionally, mothballs were used to protect materials like wool, cashmere, and fur—fabrics especially prone to insect infestations.
However, while mothballs can be effective against pests, the high concentration of chemicals necessary to repel modern pesticide-resistant insects also poses significant health risks to humans and pets. Prolonged exposure to mothball vapors in enclosed spaces can lead to various health problems, prompting many to reconsider their use.
What can mothballs be used for?
Though primarily used to protect clothing, mothballs have been applied in a variety of other household scenarios due to their strong odor and pesticidal properties. Some common uses include:
- Wool rugs: Mothball flakes sprinkled under rolled-up wool rugs prevent larvae from hatching and consuming the fibers during long storage periods.
- Upholstered furniture: Mothballs have been used in the crevices of furniture filled with natural materials, like horsehair or wool, to prevent moth infestations. Sofas and chairs often harbor moth eggs in their stuffing, which the mothballs target.
- Stuffed taxidermy: Museum curators and collectors have used mothballs to preserve taxidermy specimens vulnerable to insect damage. The chemicals protect fur, feathers, and wool felt from larvae.
- Animal-based material collections: Mothballs were used to protect valuable collections made from wool, leather, or other animal products, such as stamps, butterfly collections, or antique items.
- Vacant cabins and attics: Mothballs were often placed in seasonal structures, such as cabins or attics, to prevent rodents and insects from nesting during vacancy. However, with the rise of pesticide-resistant pests, mothballs are becoming less effective for this purpose.
Despite their many uses, mothballs have become less popular due to their health risks, limited effectiveness, and the availability of safer alternatives.
What are mothballs made of?
Mothballs are made of two primary chemicals—naphthalene or paradichlorobenzene—each with distinct properties but similar effects:
- Naphthalene: A volatile compound derived from coal tar or petroleum, naphthalene sublimates at room temperature, turning from solid to gas and releasing toxic fumes. It has a sweet, unpleasant odor detectable at very low concentrations.
- Paradichlorobenzene: Made by chlorinating benzene, paradichlorobenzene also emits a harsh chemical smell. Unlike naphthalene, it maintains its solid form and doesn't sublimate as quickly, though it’s still highly toxic.
Both chemicals are water-resistant and cling to surfaces, making them effective for long-term pest control. However, their potency and longevity also heighten health risks for humans and animals exposed to their fumes.
How do mothballs work?
Mothballs work by killing and repelling moths and their larvae through two primary mechanisms:
- Toxic fumes: Mothball vapors poison insects by penetrating their respiratory systems, attacking their nervous systems, and damaging their digestive tracts. In confined spaces like closets or storage containers, the fumes concentrate and increase mortality rates.
- Odor repellency: Moths rely on their sense of smell to find food sources, such as wool and silk. The strong odor of mothballs overwhelms their senses, discouraging them from laying eggs on fabrics.
However, as moths and other pests have become more resistant to pesticides, mothballs are losing their effectiveness. This requires higher levels of vapor concentration, which simultaneously increases the risks of toxic exposure to humans and pets.
Why are mothballs banned in the EU?
Mothballs were banned for household use in the European Union in the 1990s due to concerns about health and environmental toxicity. While they are still permitted for professional use, such as in museums or textile preservation, their use in homes is no longer allowed. The EU’s decision was based on research showing the harmful effects of exposure to mothball fumes in poorly ventilated areas.
Key reasons for the ban include:
- Health dangers: Long-term exposure to mothball fumes can cause nerve damage, respiratory problems, liver and kidney issues, and skin or eye irritation.
- Environmental impact: The chemicals in mothballs contribute to air pollution, contaminate soil and groundwater, and persist in the environment for years, posing long-term ecological risks.
Though mothballs are still available in many countries, growing awareness of these dangers has led to calls for restrictions, particularly as safer alternatives are available.
It's also important to be aware of the potential dangers mothballs pose to pets, as the chemicals used can be highly toxic to dogs and other animals.
What pests do mothballs protect from?
Mothballs are primarily known for their ability to protect against fabric-eating pests, but their pesticidal properties can also repel a range of other insects and pests in the household. Here’s a breakdown of the most common pests mothballs are effective against:
Clothes moths
The primary use of mothballs is to protect clothing from clothes moths, particularly Tineola bisselliella (the common clothes moth) and Tinea pellionella (the case-bearing clothes moth). These moths are drawn to natural fibers such as wool, cashmere, and fur, where they lay eggs. When the larvae hatch, they feed on the fibers, causing holes and damage to fabrics. Mothballs release toxic fumes that disrupt this process by killing the larvae and repelling adult moths, preventing them from infesting stored items.
Carpet beetles
Carpet beetles, particularly Anthrenus verbasci (the varied carpet beetle), are another common target of mothballs. Like clothes moths, these beetles feed on natural fibers and can cause serious damage to rugs, upholstery, and stored fabrics. Mothballs are effective in preventing carpet beetle infestations by killing larvae before they have a chance to destroy textiles.
Silverfish
Silverfish are known for their ability to consume a wide range of materials, including paper, adhesives, and fabrics. They thrive in dark, damp environments, such as attics, basements, and storage areas. Mothballs can help deter silverfish from settling in these areas, preventing damage to items like books, papers, and stored fabrics.
Rodents (limited effectiveness)
Although mothballs are not specifically designed to repel rodents, some people have historically used them in attempts to deter mice and rats. The strong, unpleasant smell of mothballs can act as a temporary deterrent in confined spaces. However, mothballs are not a long-term solution for rodent control, and their effectiveness in this regard is limited. Professional pest control or more targeted rodent repellents are recommended for dealing with mice and rats.
Other insects
In addition to their primary role in fabric protection, mothballs can sometimes repel other small insects, such as cockroaches and ants, though this is not their main purpose. The strong vapors released by mothballs can discourage these pests from settling in enclosed spaces like closets, attics, and drawers.
The dangers of mothballs
The health and environmental risks associated with mothballs are significant, even in countries where they are still available for household use. Key dangers include:
- Indoor air quality: Mothball fumes can degrade air quality, especially in enclosed spaces. Prolonged exposure can lead to respiratory issues such as persistent coughing, asthma, and breathing difficulties.
- Lifespan volatility: Unlike many other insecticides, mothballs emit harmful fumes for months after use, posing long-term risks if used without proper ventilation.
- Child safety: Mothballs are highly toxic if ingested, and thousands of children are hospitalized each year due to accidental poisoning. Even with the addition of bittering agents, ingesting even a small number of mothballs can be fatal to young children.
- Environmental contamination: Once released into the environment, mothball chemicals persist for years and accumulate in the food chain. Their runoff can also poison plants, soil, and groundwater.
Difference between mothballs and repellents
Mothballs and natural repellents like cedar are often used interchangeably, but there are important distinctions between them:
- Mothballs: These rely on chemical fumes to kill and repel moths. They are effective in high concentrations but pose significant health and environmental risks.
- Cedar repellents: Cedar-based products use natural oils to confuse and repel moths without harming humans or animals. They are effective at low concentrations and improve air quality instead of degrading it.
As moths become more resistant to mothballs, cedar products have become a safer, more effective option for protecting clothing and stored items.
For those wondering about the lifespan of cedar mothballs and how long they remain effective, understanding their longevity can help you make informed storage choices.
Safer alternatives to mothballs
With increasing awareness of the risks associated with mothballs, many households are turning to safer alternatives for moth protection:
- Cedar wood: Cedar blocks, chests, and sachets naturally repel moths by releasing insect-confusing oils. These oils are safe for humans and pets and emit a pleasant scent.
- Dried herb sachets: Herbs like lavender, rosemary, thyme, and mint contain natural oils that repel moths. These can be placed in drawers or storage containers to protect clothing.
- Cedar oil sprays: Concentrated cedar oil sprays can be applied around closets or storage areas for long-lasting protection without toxicity.
- Diatomaceous earth: This fine powder is a natural insect killer that works by desiccating larvae. It can be sprinkled in attics, storage containers, or cracks to protect against infestations.
While mothballs may seem like an old-fashioned solution passed down through generations, safer and more effective alternatives now offer better protection without the risks to your family’s health.